Oklahoma Bar Journal
Appellate Practice
Triggering the Time To Appeal in Civil Cases: The Owens Decision
By Ann Hadrava
OVERVIEW OF OWENS V. OWENS
The Oklahoma Supreme Court’s opinion in Owens v. Owens, decided in 2023,[i] marked a profound change to the court’s jurisdictional inquiry to determine whether an appeal is timely filed. Owens effectively overruled prior caselaw used to determine timeliness.
Whether you are an aggrieved party contemplating filing an appeal, a party who prevailed in the case and are preparing and serving the appealable order, or a court clerk, judge, or other person responsible for service of an appealable order, this article is intended to provide guidance on the importance of the certificate of service requirement. First, some background of the rules and statutes which govern service of orders.
12 O.S. §696.2(B) provides that a file-stamped copy of a judgment, decree, or appealable order shall be served “by the counsel for a party or party who prepared it, or by a person designated by the trial court,” no later than three days after it is filed. The statute also requires that service be done in the manner provided by 12 O.S. §2005, and a certificate of service must be filed with the district court clerk. The certificate of service must show the name of the person served and the date, time, and method of service.[ii]
12 O.S. §990A provides that an appeal must be commenced by filing a petition in error with the Supreme Court Clerk within 30 days[iii] of the date the judgment, decree, or appealable order prepared in conformance with 12 O.S. §696.3 is filed with the clerk of the trial court.[iv] However, if the appellant did not prepare the judgment or appealable order, and Section 696.2 required a copy of the judgment or appealable order to be served upon the appellant and court records do not reflect service to the appellant within three days, the petition in error may be filed “within thirty (30) days after the earliest date on which the court records show that a copy of the judgment, decree, or appealable order was served.”
In Owens, the court addressed the question whether court records reflected service of the order appealed was accomplished within three business days after the judgment was filed in compliance with Sections 990A and 696.2(B). The court began by citing Section 990A, and noted:
[I]f the party wishing to appeal also happens to have prepared the judgment, the 30-day clock begins on the date the judgment is filed with the court clerk. Otherwise, the appeal clock does not start until proof of service on the aggrieved party has been filed of record. There is a reward for promptness, however. If proof of service is filed within three business days of the filing of the judgment itself (as required by Section 696.2(B)), then the appeal start date is “backdated” to the earlier date.[v]
The district court record reflected that a certificate of service was filed within three days of the judgment, but the certificate of service was left blank where the date of service was to be inserted. Therefore, it was not clear from the “court record” when the order was mailed to the appellant.
The court found the appeal was timely filed, even though the petition in error was filed 1) more than 30 days after the filing of the judgment and 2) more than 30 days after appellant confirmed receiving a copy of the judgment, or receiving “actual notice” of the judgment.[vi] This marked a significant departure from the court’s reliance on actual notice to determine timeliness exemplified by its trilogy of actual notice cases, Tidemark Exploration, Inc. v. Good,[vii] Whitehall Homeowners, Ass’n v. Appletree Enterprise, Inc.,[viii] and State ex rel. Okla. Dep’t of Transp. v. Cedars Group, LLC.[ix]
The court recognized that both service of the judgment and proof of service of the judgment are statutorily required to trigger the time to appeal but also serve the important dual function of fair notice to litigants and efficient administration for courts.[x] The court held that the appeal will be considered timely “if proof of service is absent, unless it is clear that the appellant prepared the judgment. If proof of service is present, then the date such proof was filed will be used to determine when the 30-day appeal time began.”[xi]
Owens overruled Tidemark, Whitehall, and Cedars to the extent the jurisdictional inquiry in those cases was based on actual notice and inconsistent with the court’s holding.[xii] The Owens decision is incorporated into Supreme Court 1.21, titled, “Computation of Time for Commencement of Appeal.”[xiii]
EXAMPLES OF THE SUPREME COURT’S APPLICATION OF OWENS
While not exhaustive of the timeliness inquiries that have come before the court since Owens was decided, the following question-and-answer scenarios are taken from actual cases and should serve as a guideline for your appeal.
Scenario 1
Under 12 O.S. §990A, an order must be served within three days of the filing of the order. A certificate of service must be filed showing service was effected within three days. Does this mean the certificate of service must also be filed within the same three-day period for the date of the filing of the order to trigger the period to appeal?
Yes. The judgment was filed on Oct. 20, 2023. On Oct. 27, 2023, appellee filed a certificate of service stating the judgment was mailed to appellant on Oct. 23, 2023. In other words, the certificate of service was filed more than three days after the judgment was filed, but stated that the judgment was served within three days of its filing. This was not sufficient to have the date of the filing of the judgment trigger the 30-day period to appeal. In this scenario, Oct. 27, 2023, would trigger the period to appeal. The court denied the motion to dismiss and allowed the appeal to proceed as timely filed.[xiv]
Scenario 2
An order denying appellant’s motion to compel arbitration was filed March 3, 2025. There was no certificate of service. Litigation proceeded. Appellees mailed the order to appellant in August 2025. However, the order was attached as an exhibit to a motion. The motion had a certificate of service. Appellant commenced an appeal after the judge provided a copy of the order to appellant in March 2026. Appellees moved to dismiss the appeal as untimely. Under Owens, did the certificate of service attached to the August 2025 motion to which the appealable order was appended constitute “proof of service” of the judgment to trigger the time to appeal?[xv]
No. The service requirement in Section 696.2(B) refers to the appealable judgment. Also, under Section 696.2(B), a “certificate of service must be filed with the court clerk.” There was a certificate of service, but it was not attached or specific to the appealable order. Practically speaking, the record would not readily show the judgment was served by the filing of an entirely separate document. The record would not show the judgment was filed with the district court clerk, unless one was reading through the trial court record.[xvi]
Scenario 3
A hearing was conducted in the trial court. The same day, the judgment was filed. Both attorneys signed the journal entry. There was no certificate of service. The petition in error was filed more than 30 days after the judgment. Appellee moved to dismiss as untimely on grounds appellant participated in preparation of the journal entry. Under Owens, does this show appellant “prepared the judgment” to trigger the 30-day period?
No. Under Owens, it must be “clear” that the appellant prepared the judgment, and the presence of the attorney’s signature was not enough to find the attorney also prepared the judgment. The motion to dismiss was denied, and the appeal was allowed to proceed.[xvii]
Scenario 4
The certificate of service to the judgment was prepared by the court clerk and indicated the order was emailed to the parties, but not to their physical mailing addresses of record. Appellee moved to dismiss the appeal as untimely.
12 O.S. §2005 allows service of papers by electronic means only if the party gives written consent in an entry of appearance or in another pleading filed by that party. There was nothing in the record indicating consent. Did the proof of service satisfy Owens?
No. Court records must show service in conformance with the rules and statutes, including statutes governing electronic service..[xviii]
Scenario 5
The judgment was entered May 30, 2023. The certificate of service stated, “I do hereby certify that on the ___ day of May 2023, a copy of the judgment was mailed.” All other requirements for a certificate of service were met. The appeal was filed more than 30 days after the filing of the order. Appellee moved to dismiss the appeal as untimely.
Because we know the month of May has 31 days, one could assume the order was mailed on either May 30 or May 31, because the month of May appeared in the blank. Did the proof of service satisfy Owens?
No. For the certificate of service to be effective, it must be complete. The motion to dismiss was denied and the appeal was allowed to proceed.[xix]
While the court in Owens held that the “petition will be accepted as timely if proof of service is absent, unless it is clear that the appellant prepared the judgment,”[xx] litigants should not overlook a potential caveat to Owens found in footnote 16 of the opinion. In that footnote, the court recognized that in some jurisdictions, courts have held that “even when record proof of service is absent, appeal time will start if the aggrieved party takes some affirmative action, evident from the record, which evinces actual knowledge.” That is, where an appealing party not only has knowledge but acts upon such knowledge, and such action appears of record, this could serve as a distinct act of waiver.[xxi]
For example, where there is a judgment lacking proper service, and the aggrieved party does not appeal, but subsequent filings in the district court indicate the aggrieved party is aware of the judgment and takes steps to actively litigate the judgment, Owens suggests this could result in dismissal of the appeal as untimely brought if the judgment is later appealed.
The scenarios provided are not all inclusive. Facts vary. The rule of thumb if you are the appellant: Assume the appeal time is triggered by the date the order is filed in the district court (or other tribunal), and file your appeal within the required time period.[xxii] If you are the appellee: File a proper certificate of service within three days of the filing of the judgment to ensure the filing of the judgment triggers the appeal time. As the court in Owens noted, “There is a reward for promptness,” and a certificate of service filed in compliance with 12 O.S. §696.2(B) will trigger the time to appeal.[xxiii]
This article is intended to hit the highlights of the Owens decision. I encourage you to read the opinion in its entirety. It contains a good discussion of the 1997 amendments to 12 O.S. §990A, runs through the factual history and analysis of the actual notice cases in Tidemark, Whitehall, and Cedars, explains the flaws associated with the timeliness analysis under that rubric, and reconciles its holding as more consistent with legislative intent.
Author’s Note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Oklahoma Supreme Court or any of its justices.
This article expands on a CLE that Referee Meredith Wolfe and the author presented to the OBA Appellate Practice Section in September 2025. Portions of this article also draw upon an article published in the October 2019 issue of the Oklahoma Bar Journal, Vol. 90 No. 8, titled, “Appealable Orders: Asking the Key Questions,” available to OBA members via HeinOnline. This article is meant to be a general overview only. Always consult the relevant statutes, appellate rules, and rules for district courts in each case.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Ann Hadrava is a referee at the Oklahoma Supreme Court. Prior to coming to the court in January of 2017, she was in private practice, focusing mostly on appellate work. She also has prior legal experience in the executive and legislative branches. Ms. Hadrava graduated in 2002 from the OCU School of Law.
ENDNOTES
[i] 2023 OK 12, 529 P.3d 905.
[ii] Rule 2, Rules for District Courts, Tit. 12, ch. 2, App.
[iii] This article will mostly refer to the 30-day appeal requirement governing regular appeals from the district courts. See 12 O.S. §990A. See also Okla. Sup. Ct. R. 1.21. However, there is a 20-day requirement applicable to a workers’ compensation petition for review. See Okla. Sup. Ct. R. 1.100. Regular counter-appeals must be commenced within 30 days of a timely-filed petition in error. See Okla. Sup. Ct. R. 1.27(a). Always double check what type of appeal you have because some are governed by specific statutes and appellate rules other than those mentioned in this article.
[iv] The first rule of an appeal is the order appealed must be properly memorialized. This is a jurisdictional requirement. 12 O.S. §696.2(A) provides that after the granting of a judgment, decree, or appealable order, it shall be reduced to writing in conformance with 12 O.S. §696.3. Section 696.2(D) provides examples of what does not constitute an appealable order. The most common unappealable order the court sees is the “minute entry” or “summary order.” Remember, an order disposing of a post-trial motion must also be memorialized in conformance with these statutory requirements. For cases discussing proper memorialization of orders, see Laubach v. Laubach, 2022 OK 78, ¶14, 561 P.3d 54, and Moore v. Haley, 2021 OK 37, 505 P.3d 918.
[v] Owens v. Owens, 2023 OK 12, ¶5, 529 P.3d 905.
[vi] Actual notice, as discussed by the dissent in Tidemark Exploration, Inc. v. Good, 1998 OK 67, ¶3, 967 P.2d 1194 (Summers, V.C.J., dissenting) refers to the date on which a party possesses knowledge of the date of filing of the judgment. Prior to Owens, actual notice of an appealable event triggered the running of the time to appeal. Tidemark, at ¶6. L’ggrke v. Sherman, 2009 OK 80, ¶8, n.11, 223 P.3d 383.
[vii] 1998 OK 67, ¶5, 967 P.2d 1194, 1195-96.
[viii] 2012 OK 34, ¶12, 277 P.3d 1266, 1269.
[ix] 2013 OK 99, ¶8, 320 P.3d 23, 25.
[x] Owens, 2023 OK 12, at ¶26.
[xi] Id. at ¶30.
[xii] Because the trilogy of actual notice cases was overruled to the extent that they were inconsistent with Owens, the discussion of these cases in “Appealable Orders: Asking the Key Questions,” referenced supra note 1, should not be relied upon.
[xiii] Rule 1.21, Oklahoma Supreme Court Rules, Tit. 12, ch. 15, App. 1.
[xiv] Hester Anne Brown v. Nathan Scott Gilley, Case No. 121,789.
[xv] This appeal remains pending.
[xvi] Supreme Court Rule 1.21(a), amended in 2023 after Owens v. Owens, 2023 OK 12, 529 P.3d 905, was decided states:
If the appellant did not prepare the judgment, decree, or appealable order, and Section 696.2 of this title required a copy of the judgment, decree, or appealable order to be mailed to the appellant, the appellee may limit the appellant’s time for lodging an appeal by filing proof of service on the appellant with the district court clerk. See 12 O.S. §990A(A); Owen v. Owens, 2023 OK 12.
[xvii] Emily Kate Ferguson v. Jearamy Hendrix, Case No. 123,156.
[xviii] Firstar Bank v. Garrett Thomas Kizzia, Case No. 122,883.
[xix] J&A, L.L.C. v. Bobby Strickland Sr. and Emma Strickland, Case No. 121,689.
[xx] Owens, 2023 OK 12, at ¶30.
[xxi] Id. at ¶30, at n. 16.
[xxii] The court noted that while proof of service is required to trigger the time to appeal, the absence of such proof does not prevent the appellant from commencing the appeal. Owens, 2023 OK 12, at n. 15.
[xxiii] Owens, 2023 OK 12, at ¶5.
Originally published in the Oklahoma Bar Journal – OBJ 97 No. 9 (November 2026)
Statements or opinions expressed in the Oklahoma Bar Journal are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Oklahoma Bar Association, its officers, Board of Governors, Board of Editors or staff.