Oklahoma Bar Journal

Appellate Practice

Recent Amendments to District Court Rule 15, Disqualification of Judges: What You Need to Know

By Ann Hadrava

AN OVERVIEW OF THE AMENDMENTS TO RULE 15

The procedure for judicial disqualification is found in Rule 15, Rules for District Courts of Oklahoma.[i] The rule was most recently amended by the Supreme Court in 2024 and 2026, with the most recent amendments taking effect June 1.[ii] Practitioners and judges, particularly in the civil context, are encouraged to familiarize themselves with these changes, as the most recent amendments mark a departure from the previous version of Rule 15 in both timing and procedural requirements.[iii]

Many of you may be familiar with the 2024 amendments, which could be considered threefold.[iv] First, the amendments clarified that upon the written motion to disqualify, a judge may not proceed with the case until the disqualification process is fully exhausted. They also clarified that nothing in the rule precludes another judge from proceeding in the case pending resolution of the motion to disqualify the assigned judge.[v] Secondly, a judge who is recused or disqualified from the case may not participate in the selection of the successor judge.[vi]

Finally, the 2024 amendments authorized the imposition of sanctions for the filing of a frivolous motion to disqualify a judge. Rule 15(f) tracks the language in Supreme Court Rule 1.191(j), which provides for sanctions for the filing of a frivolous original proceeding. Rule 15(f) defines a frivolous proceeding to disqualify or recuse a judge as one “brought for the sole purpose of delay or to disrupt the proceeding or a motion so obviously without any merit as to impute bad faith on the party seeking disqualification or recusal.”[vii]

Though it was decided before the amendments, Frazier v. Bruce, 2021 OK 14, 484 P.3d 285, is an example of the court’s imposition of sanctions in the disqualification context. The court considered both the basis for disqualification and the conduct of the movant in the proceedings leading up to the motion for disqualification.[viii]

Three of the most significant changes made in 2026 can be found in Rule 15(a), which states:

Before filing any motion to disqualify or recuse a trial judge… an in camera request shall first be made to the judge to disqualify. Such in camera request shall not be made ex parte. If such in camera request is not satisfactorily resolved, a motion to disqualify the judge may be filed pursuant to 20 O.S. 2025, § 1403, provided such motion is not being filed less than ten (10) days before the case is set for trial. Such motion must be filed within ten (10) days of the judge’s denial of the in camera request. A copy of the motion shall be delivered to the judge’s chambers. Until such time as the formal motion is filed, the assigned judge may proceed with the case.

 

First, the prior version of Rule 15 did not specify whether an in camera request could or should be made to the judge ex parte. The rule now clarifies that the request shall not be made ex parte and requires notification of the other parties of the movant’s in camera request.

            Second, the prior version of Rule 15 did not specify a time period for the filing of a formal written motion to disqualify after the movant’s in camera request was not satisfactorily resolved. As a consequence, cases saw wide variations of time passing between the denial of an in camera request and the filing of a formal written motion. Now, should the movant wish to proceed with the Rule 15 proceeding, the movant must file a formal written motion within 10 days of the judge’s denial of the in camera request.

            Finally, the prior version of Rule 15 did not require the judge to refrain from proceeding in the case after a movant’s in camera request was denied, but before the filing of a formal written motion to disqualify. Still, some judges felt it best and in the spirit of Rule 15 to stay the proceedings and direct the movant to file a written motion within a given period. Others did not stay proceedings since there was no set time period for filing a written motion to disqualify after the denial of an in camera request, other than the motion could not be less than 10 days before the case was set for trial. Now, the rule specifies that up until the filing of a motion to disqualify, the assigned judge may (but is not required to) proceed with the case.[ix]

THE IMPORTANCE OF MEMORIALIZATION AND SERVICE OF RULE 15 ORDERS

The prior version of District Court Rule 15(b) provided that the party aggrieved by the “original order” denying a written motion to disqualify or transfer a cause to another judge could re-present the motion to the chief judge or presiding judge. If the hearing before the second judge resulted in an “order” adverse to the movant, the movant could then seek relief in the Supreme Court or the Court of Criminal Appeals. However, the language in Rule 15 left it unclear whether such an order was required to be memorialized in conformance with 12 O.S. §§696.2 and 696.3, which is a “jurisdictional prerequisite to the commencement of an appeal” from a judgment, decree, or an appealable order even though a Rule 15 proceeding is not considered an appeal.[x]

In Clark v. Board of Educ. of Ind. Sch. Dist. No. 89,[xi] the Supreme Court held that a challenge to a judge for want of impartiality must be resolved by a “ruling memorialized of record.” The court explained that an entry on the appearance docket does not satisfy the “on-the-record” requirement.[xii] In Miller Dollarhide, P.C. v. Tal,[xiii] the court reiterated the rule from Clark that a request to recuse must have a “memorialized ruling.” These cases did not really answer the question of how such an order should be memorialized and whether the order required a certificate of service to trigger the next phase of the Rule 15 proceeding.

Now, Rule 15(g) clarifies that in a civil proceeding, “the date of the filing of an order prepared in conformance with 12 O.S. 2025, §§696.2 and 696.3 commences the running of the time periods as prescribed in this rule.”[xiv] The rule describes how the time period should be computed and notes the additional three days granted by the “mailbox rule” in 12 O.S. 2025, §2006(D) do not apply to the time periods prescribed in Rule 15. Be aware, this does not apply in a criminal proceeding, and the running of the time period in a criminal proceeding is calculated differently as provided in Rule 15(h).

As the court in Moore v. Haley[xv] noted, many times a summary order, minute order, or court minute and other forms of informal rulings may not contain the full caption or other information and may not include a certificate of mailing, leaving “uncertainty” for litigants about the finality of such an order for purposes of triggering the next procedural stage. Sometimes such rulings are followed by a formal journal entry, creating confusion as to which ruling triggers the next phase.[xvi]

The addition of Rule 15(g) also marks a significant change to Rule 15, one aimed at consistency and clarity as to what is necessary to trigger the next phase of Rule 15 as contemplated in Clark. The rationale is not unlike that of Owens. The change ensures proper notice of the court’s ruling will be provided to all parties affected. The rationale for requiring that an appealable order be memorialized and served in conformance with 12 O.S. §§696.2 and 696.3 to trigger the time to appeal applies equally in the context of Rule 15, especially given the rule’s shortened time periods for proceeding to the next step.

The takeaway from this requirement? It should treated the same as an appeal. For example, if a party institutes an original proceeding in the Supreme Court after an adverse ruling on rehearing/representment and the ruling or order is not memorialized in conformance with 12 O.S. §§696.2 and 696.3, it is likely the Supreme Court will deem the original proceeding premature.[xvii]

As noted above, Rule 15(h) applies to a criminal proceeding and specifies that the running of the time periods prescribed in the rule are triggered from the date the order is announced, or the order is filed of record, whichever occurs first. Moreover, the computation will use calendar days, as opposed to the business-day application, which applies to a civil or non-criminal proceeding.

In the last two years, District Court Rule 15 has undergone a significant overhaul for the better. Hopefully this overview of the changes will be helpful, whether you are a practitioner who may have occasion to invoke the recusal or disqualification procedure, a practitioner on the other side of a motion for recusal or disqualification, or a judge who is presented with a recusal or disqualification motion.

 

Author’s Note: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Oklahoma Supreme Court or any of its justices.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ann Hadrava is a referee at the Oklahoma Supreme Court. Prior to coming to the court in January of 2017, she was in private practice, focusing mostly on appellate work. She also has prior legal experience in the executive and legislative branches. Ms. Hadrava graduated in 2002 from the OCU School of Law.

 

 

 


ENDNOTES

[i] O.S., Tit. 12, ch. 2, App. Rule 15 was most recently amended on April 6, 2026, by order of the Supreme Court, 2026 OK 21, and took effect June 1, 2026.

[ii] The pre-2024 version of Rule 15 was in effect for decades.

[iii] 20 O.S. §1403, the statutory procedure for disqualification, was also amended in 2026. These changes take effect Nov. 1, 2026. Section 1403 tracks much of the same language as Rule 15. However, unlike Rule 15, the statute provides timelines for the motion to disqualify and motion for rehearing to be ruled upon. Section 1403(A) states the “judge shall rule upon the disqualification motion within fifteen (15) days from the date it is filed.” Section 1403(B) requires the rehearing to be held and ruled upon with 30 days from the filing of the application for rehearing. See Laws 2026, HB 4226, c. 221, §1, eff. Nov. 1, 2026.

[iv] O.S., Tit. 12, ch. 2, App. Rule 15 was previously amended by order of the Supreme Court, 2024 OK 79, effective Nov. 18, 2024.

[v] Rule 15(d).

[vi] Rule 15(e).

[vii] Rule 15(f).

[viii] As the court stated,

[T]he Court will not ignore the behavior of the parties in the proceedings that led to a party invoking Rule 15 and seeking the judge’s disqualification. Nor will it ignore a party’s prior sanctioned-conduct in the underlying litigation.

Frazier v. Bruce, 2021 OK 14, ¶2, 484 P.3d 285.

[ix] Sections (b) through (f) of Rule 15 did not undergo any changes, except for Section (b) was broken down into paragraphs (1) through (4) for clarity of reading.

[x] 12 O.S. §696.2(D).

[xi] 2001 OK 56, ¶7, 32 P.3d 851.

[xii] Id. at n.12.

[xiii] 2007 OK 58, ¶10, 163 P.3d 548.     

[xiv] This does not apply to a criminal proceeding, and such proceedings are governed by Rule 15(h).

[xv] 2021 OK 37, ¶3, 505 P.3d 918.

[xvi] Id.

[xvii] Before Rule 15 was amended, the Supreme Court required that in a proceeding filed in the Supreme Court seeking a writ of mandamus to disqualify the assigned judge, the ruling denying rehearing/representment be memorialized in conformance with 12 O.S. §§696.2 and 696.3. E.g., Case No. 122,854, Hibbard v. Pazzo; Case No. 122,882, Wynn Solutions, LLC v. Virgin. In both cases, before considering the merits, the court directed the chief/presiding judge to prepare an order denying the rehearing in compliance with the requirements of 12 O.S.§§ 696.2 and 696.3, and to include a certificate of service per statutory requirements.

 


Originally published in the Oklahoma Bar Journal – OBJ 97 No. 9 (November 2026)

Statements or opinions expressed in the Oklahoma Bar Journal are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Oklahoma Bar Association, its officers, Board of Governors, Board of Editors or staff.